Skip to content
Sure Edition

Letterboxd's Most Enthusiastic Critics Are Shifting Film-Going Norms: I Couldn't Wait to Pull Out My Phone'

I consistently completely turn off my cellphone when I enter a theater. Not simply on vibrate – completely off. I mention this not to boast, or to suggest that the ghost of a film legend will return to shake my hand. I view it as one of life's small luxuries: for a minimum of ninety minutes, I am totally incommunicado. I leave my phone deactivated for the duration of the scroll as well. It seems luxurious to remain seated as other patrons gradually exit, bathed in the light of the scrolling names.

And, increasingly, by the glow of the Letterboxd application.

In excess of 26 million people utilize Letterboxd, a film-cataloguing app. Similar to the Criterion Collection, it has become industry shorthand for a specific type of influencer who champions new releases and finds joy in unearthing old classics. Members rate and review films, and the funniest or most profound critiques ascend to the top, motivating film lovers to put in effort.

"If I don't jot down my ideas quickly when the film concludes, my critiques are much less coherent and articulate," remarked a student.

In a recent outing to the cinema, the end titles had just begun before the man ahead of me commenced writing his assessment. Not far away, a duo lingered, focused on their screens, recording their respective thoughts.

The renowned film-maker David Lynch had a piece of advice: write down every brilliant thought the exact moment it comes to mind. If you don't, it could vanish, and, in his words: "Forgetting a great idea, you feel like you could commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to aspiring film-makers, the same principle applies to the Letterboxd experience.

Josh Stern, a young university attendee in New York, always drafts his reviews from his theater seat.

"Unless I jot down my ideas promptly when the film concludes, my write-ups are far less clear and eloquent," he explained. "It takes a bit. I'm not a fast writer, and my significant other isn't fond of it."

He visits the movies frequently – 182 times the previous year – and is on a first-name basis with the cinema employees, who occasionally have to ask him to leave so they can begin cleaning the aisles. He believes it acceptable to take advantage of the credit sequence: "Upon buying a movie ticket, the credits are part of the feature."

The app's most fervent supporters attribute the app with reviving excitement around a challenged cinema sector, where productions are down and unemployment is up. (Letterboxd also possesses the sort of user profile brands desire – its biggest group of users is between 18 and 24, followed by 25 to 35.)

Hype generates additional buzz; much-hyped movies see a flurry of engagement on Letterboxd immediately after the first showings. The highest-rated review of a divisive film version – "the author died long ago yet this version is still the worst thing that has ever happened to her" – has garnered more than 50,000 hearts. A separate recent film generated this contrast to a rival's documentary: "a famous concert movie left in the dust."

"It's a little a habit," remarked one user, a 33-year-old New Yorker who is employed in marketing. He also likes to jot down thoughts throughout the end sequence. "Thinking about what you just witnessed, immediately after you watched it, aids the artistic experience. It helps you grasp the key messages of a film. If it produces a sense of comfort, that's not always something you remember five hours down the line."

Glidden feels most motivated to critique a film if it was very good – or exceptionally bad. For example: he recently sat through a sci-fi film. "I was so appalled by how profoundly awful it was, that I was eager to whip out my phone and assign it a one-half star rating," he noted. (He is a tougher critic than some reviewers, who assigned the film three stars, calling it "smart and entertaining stuff.")

Dakota Chester, a 28-year-old professional who works in social media, viewed an acclaimed feature at a cinema on the Upper West Side and lingered to write the review ("I gave it five stars"). He has clocked more egregious conduct: people pulling out their phones to Letterboxd the movie they are currently watching. "That irritates me," he said.

One of film's most enduring urban legends describes a exhibition of a pioneering film that featured a train pulling into a station. Cinema was in its formative period and – in line with this largely discredited anecdote – the footage of a locomotive charging directly toward the camera frightened the crowd so much that people ran away in panic.

Many decades later, audience behavior can be just as problematic. Often, individuals knows how to conduct themselves any more, especially when the theater darkens: patrons use their phones of the projection, bring in smelly food, and, as was reported during a cultural moment, at times participate in physical altercations.

A number of users have turned to social media to debate the propriety of "Letterboxding" during the end sequence. When one social media user

The writer

Kathleen Serrano

A digital publishing strategist with over a decade of experience in content innovation and media transformation.

Sure Edition

Type to search articles.